Nurses Under Fire: The Stress of Medical Malpractice

Gail Fiore

Just because nurses are sued less often than doctors doesn't mean that their actions aren't a focus of a large number of medical malpractice lawsuits. Whether they are defendants or not, nurses are often crucial to the defense and subject to the same stress as the physicians they work with. A condition known as medical malpractice stress syndrome (MMSS) is increasingly being recognized as affecting medical professionals who are subjected to litigation.

According to a 2019 report by CRICO, the risk management arm of Harvard's medical facilities, nursing was a "primary service" in 34% of cases with a high-severity injury and in 44% of cases that were closed with a payment. And even though nurses were named as defendants only 14% of the time, likely because many nurses don't have their own personal malpractice coverage, their hospitals or facilities were sued in most of these cases — making the nurses important witnesses for the defense.

We have every reason to believe that things have gotten worse since the CRICO study was published. Chronic nursing shortages were exacerbated during the COVID pandemic, and we have seen a large number of nurses leave the workforce altogether. In a recent survey of nurses by Hospital IQ, 90% of respondents said they were considering leaving the nursing profession in the next year, with 71% of nurses who have more than 15 years of nursing experience thinking about leaving within the next few months.

Those remaining are faced with increased workloads and extra shifts — often mandated — and working with too little sleep. Their commitment to their mission is heroic, but they are only human; it's hard to imagine the number of errors, the number of bad outcomes, and the number of lawsuits going anywhere but up.

And of course, the entire profession has been fixated on the recent case of the Tennessee nurse who was prosecuted criminally and convicted in connection with a fatal medication error.

These are all reasons to expect that an increasing number of nurses are going to be trying to cope with symptoms of MMSS. Too many of them will initially be viewed by lawyers or claims professionals as simply defensive, arrogant, or difficult to work with. In fact, it's impossible to know how many cases are settled just to avoid the risk of such a "difficult client" being deposed.

These caring, hard-working, and committed individuals have had their lives shaken in ways that they never expected. Nurses with MMSS need support, but traditional psychotherapy, with a diffuse focus and long-time horizon, is not the most effective option. What's necessary is practical support that is short-term, goal oriented, and tailored to the specifics of the pending litigation process.

Most important, they need to know that they are not experiencing this alone, that MMSS is a common phenomenon, and that a productive coaching relationship can be highly effective.

When approached and supported effectively, nurses — and indeed all medical professionals — can regain their confidence and focus, continue having productive professional and personal lives, and reduce the likelihood of a downhill spiral. And it makes it more likely that they'll remain in the profession rather than becoming just another statistic in the ever-worsening shortage of nurses in the United States.

Gail Fiore is president of The Winning Focus, LLC, which works with physicians and other professionals involved in litigation who are having difficulty coping with stress, anxiety, and other emotional issues.

Follow Medscape on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube

Medscape Nurses © 2022 WebMD, LLC

Any views expressed above are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect the views of WebMD or Medscape.

Cite this: Nurses Under Fire: The Stress of Medical Malpractice - Medscape - May 13, 2022.