The Basics Versus Technology: Which Wins?

Physicians Are Talking About…

The Basics Versus Technology: Which Wins?

Brandon Cohen

Disclosures

April 09, 2018

37

A recent article featured a discussion between Drs Charles P. Vega and Fabrizia Faustinella in which they posed the provocative question of whether doctors had gotten lazy, particularly when it came to performing hands-on physical exams. They described what they saw as deteriorating abilities among colleagues and residents when it came to the basics of examining patients. This spurred a robust discussion by readers about the issue.

Many physicians objected in particular to the use of the word "lazy" in the title. One internist employed sarcasm: "Yes, let's keep supporting doctor-bashing, the new sport; It might make it to the Olympics."

But others saw necessary criticism in the article:

It's not doctor-bashing; it is today's reality. I truly believe that to many young doctors, the actual laying of hands is considered a nuisance. Much easier to order expensive tests and scans. Clinical judgement is now ridiculed because it doesn't stand up in court like an MRI does. Sad but true. But it's not just young doctors; the surrounding healthcare team doesn't trust clinical acumen anymore. One of the main reasons I quit inpatient pediatrics over a decade ago.

An internist agreed:

I have noticed exactly this phenomenon as the modern practice model becomes more and more monetized.

Comments

3090D553-9492-4563-8681-AD288FA52ACE
Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. Please see our Commenting Guide for further information. We reserve the right to remove posts at our sole discretion.

processing....